Could just two weeks of eating more ultraprocessed foods change how the brain responds to something as simple as a milkshake? A new study suggests it's possible, although the findings aren't nearly as conclusive as that question might suggest.
Researchers at Virginia Tech found differences in brain activity among participants ages 18 to 21 after they followed a diet high in ultraprocessed foods. However, the same changes weren't observed in participants ages 22 to 25, and there was no significant difference when researchers looked at everyone together.
The findings, published in the journal Obesity, raise questions about whether younger people may be more sensitive to certain dietary changes. But they don't establish that ultraprocessed foods damage the brain or cause lasting changes in eating habits.
The study involved 22 adults who followed two different diets for two weeks each. One contained mostly ultraprocessed foods, while the other contained none. Both provided similar amounts of calories, protein, fat, carbohydrates, fiber, sugar and sodium, along with comparable overall nutritional quality.
That detail matters because it allowed researchers to examine whether something beyond the usual nutrients in food might influence how the brain responds to eating.
Before and after each diet, participants had brain scans while tasting small amounts of milkshake.
Among the seven youngest participants, researchers saw less activity in a part of the brain involved in food-related decisions and rewards after the ultraprocessed diet. Activity in that same area increased after the diet without ultraprocessed foods. The other 15 participants showed no significant changes.
Interestingly, earlier findings from the same experiment showed that the younger participants also ate more after following the ultraprocessed diet, even when they weren't hungry.
But the researchers couldn't link those changes in eating behavior to the differences seen in their brain scans. In other words, the study doesn't explain why those participants ate more.
It's also important to remember that a change in brain activity isn't necessarily a sign of harm. The researchers weren't measuring brain damage, and they don't know whether the differences they observed would affect everyday eating habits or persist over time.
There are other reasons for caution. The study was small, and the age-related findings came from an exploratory analysis involving just seven younger participants. Larger studies are needed to determine whether the results hold up.
Researchers also couldn't pinpoint what caused the differences. Because the two diets were nutritionally similar, they suspect other characteristics of the foods might play a role, but they couldn't determine whether additives, processing methods or something else was responsible.
And ultraprocessed foods aren't all alike. The category includes products with widely varying nutritional qualities, so the findings don't establish that every food classified as ultraprocessed has the same effect.
The study was supported by the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, part of the National Institutes of Health. Lead author Emma Leslie also received graduate fellowship support.
